Tuesday, 9 March 2010

From Windows to Ubuntu – Part One – The Decision

Alas, my poor laptop- 6 years is a lifetime for technology.  As my trusty HP notebook struggles into it’s autumn years the signs of aging are becoming very apparent.  The battery is now only good for temporary life-support while I move between rooms, the memory has been upgraded to the max, modern hard drives are incompatible and compatible drives cost more than a new laptop.  Basically it has had all the plastic surgery that is reasonably possible and now it needs to take it easy if it wants to see another Christmas.

I tried upgrading it from Windows XP to the latest Windows 7 (Vista just refused to install claiming the laptop wouldn’t be able to manage) but even the latest and greatest Windows seems to be lagging and gives my poor old ‘top a 1.0 in the experience test. 

So what else is there?  

image

Well, some would have us believe that Linux is the way to breath new life into an old machine.  Allegedly Linux based operating systems a much less resource intensive and will run much more comfortably than the clear market leader.  I intend to find out!

To clarify before we begin, I have never used Linux, at least not intentionally.  Nobody has ever been able to convince me that it is worth my time installing over Windows.  I know people will say that it is much more customisable than Windows and can be adapted to do whatever I want, but what do I want to do that I can’t do in Windows?  I spend a lot of time looking at photos, listen to music, I visit websites, write blogs, organise my finances on spreadsheets, even edit home movies from time to time, and all this happens really quite well even on Windows XP.

To me when somebody talks about how flexible and customisable something is, especially when we’re talking about software, all I think is that I’m going to be spending an entire weekend just trying to get it working.  My trusty iPhone comes with absolutely no flexibility whatsoever, and because of that everyone I know can pick it up and use it straight away.  Word is though, there is now a version of Linux that has all the flexibility of Linux but that can finally rival Windows at ease of use.  They call this miracle: Ubuntu.

So, on to the mission at hand.  Here are my objectives in this delightfully geeky exercise:
  1. Install Ubuntu onto the laptop.
  2. Get the basics working (keyboard, touchpad, sound, wireless, internet).
  3. Find suitable (free) replacements for essential apps (Word, Excel, Outlook, iTunes, Picasa, Photoshop, VLC, Windows Movie Maker).
  4. Look around for limitations- what can’t I do that I could do in Windows.
  5. Find out what I can do on Ubuntu that I couldn’t do with Windows.
  6. Establish (somehow) whether the laptop is actually working better than before.
  7. Decide whether I like Ubuntu or want to go back to Windows XP.
I will leave the biggest test to last…. the Wife test.  This is the ultimate test subject for a new operating system, the non-geek.  My wife, like most wives and non-geeks, doesn’t like it when I change things on the computer.  She hated when I switched from Vista to W7 because she had to get used to a slightly new way of doing things, so I know upfront that she will not be a willing test subject, and I wouldn’t want to know what would happen to me if I was doing this on our main desktop computer!

Anyway, I have some objectives to be getting along with.

Continue on to part two: Installation

3 comments:

  1. My wife enoyed the change from XP to ubuntu. No more crashes, viruses, malware or repeated installs and no more fear of something going "seriously" wrong. Everything just works. Which is how she likes it - simple.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Here are som alternatives to the programs you mentioned in objective #3:

    Word - Open office (comes with Ubuntu)
    Excel - Open Office
    Outlook - Evolution (comes with Ubuntu)
    iTunes - Rhythmbox (Comes with ubuntu)
    Picasa - You can get the Linux version of this from google (make sure you get the .deb file)
    Photoshop - Gimp (comes with Ubuntu)
    VLC - Linux version of this too! (install it from Ubuntu Software Center)
    Windows Movie Maker - kdenlive (Ubuntu Software Center)

    Also have a look at http://www.osalt.com/ for any other apps. And any apps you can't find an alternative to might run in Wine.

    Welcome to Ubuntu

    ReplyDelete
  3. As shall I sum up what I use in replacement for those applications.

    Word - Open Office (Pre installed)
    Excel - Open Office (Pre installed)
    Outlook - Firebird 3 (sudo apt-get install firebird in 10.04)
    Itunes - Rhythmbox (Pre installed)
    Picasa - Linux version of course, also check out fspot
    Photoshop - Gimp
    VLC - (install using: sudo apt-get install vlc)
    Windows movia maker - pitivi (Pre installed in 10.04)

    10.04 will be a big release, I suggest you don't install too much yet because it's a real good idea doing a clean install of 10.04 once it releases. And yes, you can do an update, but I'm not a fan of that, if there is a new release, I usually like a fresh start, right out of the box :).

    ReplyDelete